A common governance framework for outsourcing and service providers
How do you assess outsourcing when different teams need different evidence?
In the project for Deutsche Bank Group, longstanding contracts met differing audit requirements. I looked for criteria that all teams could apply to assess each arrangement consistently.
I helped combine regulatory requirements, internal controls and audit standards in a shared risk assessment process. The teams could use the same basis to assess new requirements.
€bn
Annual revenue · Regulatory oversight needs to work consistently at scale and stand up to audit.
Risk visibility
thousand
Employees · Align control requirements and ownership in a common governance framework.
Integrated governance
Manage outsourcing
Bring requirements, risks, controls and ownership into one approach to outsourcing oversight.
Forward-looking oversight
01 · OBJECTIVES
Project objective
The goal was a group-wide framework for existing and new outsourcing arrangements. It would connect the applicable regulations, internal controls and international audit standards and give teams a consistent approach to managing providers.
A common assessment method had to work beyond individual cases. The aim was to make the relationships between requirements traceable and avoid separate assessment processes for each one.
02 · IMPLEMENTATION
Approach
- Develop a consistent risk assessment process for new and existing providers.
- Manage material outsourcing arrangements through a common framework.
- Incorporate internal audits, service reviews and international control standards.
- Bring national and international requirements together in a consistent assessment method.
The shared structure linked professional assessment, responsibility and control requirements. It provided a basis for managing provider relationships throughout their life cycle.
03 · CHALLENGE
Challenge
Different processes, longstanding contracts and divided responsibilities made consistent oversight difficult. The project had to bring together supervisory, external audit and internal audit requirements while keeping operations manageable.
Coordination between functions was especially demanding. The method had to account for specialist differences while keeping terminology, assessment criteria and control points consistent.
04 · IMPACT
Benefits
The framework created a traceable basis for identifying, assessing and managing outsourcing. It brought together regulatory requirements and internal controls and documented a risk assessment process that could be developed over time. Supervisory and internal audits were completed successfully.
The value extended beyond a single audit. Documented assessments and a reusable approach made it easier to incorporate new requirements into existing oversight.
PROJECT BACKGROUND
Context and implementation
Project context
Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) is an international IT services and consulting company. The Deutsche Bank Group project combined regulatory interpretation, process design and technical implementation.
The task was to create a common framework for outsourcing and provider relationships and connect it to the group’s existing controls.
My contribution
In my role at the time, I helped coordinate the work with business teams, compliance, legal and IT. Existing provider relationships were catalogued and tested against common criteria to determine whether they constituted outsourcing.
I helped develop a traceable assessment method linking regulatory requirements to internal control points. Risk-based prioritisation helped focus on relevant cases. The framework could accommodate new requirements without being rebuilt.
Starting point
Before the project, outsourcing practices and responsibilities differed across the group. Historical cases were documented in part and assessed inconsistently.
The brief called for a standardised governance framework that could work at scale. The project documentation refers to MaRisk, KWG, BAIT, FISG, SOX and ISAE 3402. The framework was also intended to accommodate later developments such as DORA.
Results and impact
The resulting framework supported consistent management of outsourcing and provider relationships. Assessments became more transparent, and teams could document control points and responsibilities in a traceable way.
The modular structure made it easier to incorporate further requirements. Agreed processes and documented decisions supported group oversight and provided a basis for internal and external audits.
Further reading
THIRD-PARTY GOVERNANCE
How to manage suppliers, cloud services and digital dependenciesDIGITAL GOVERNANCE, REGULATION & RESILIENCELet’s stay in touch
Would you like to discuss any of these topics?



